Monster Cookie Protein Peanut Butter tastes like your childhood favorite cookie, only better for you! The perfect flavor from the oatmeal cream pie flavored whey protein isolate and the perfect crunch from the real M&Ms.
Because this isn’t candy in a jar.
We add M&Ms and chocolate chips to complement the monster cookie flavor and experience — not bury it under a layer of sugar. Every topping is intentional. Every ingredient earns its place.
We’re not here to win a sugar-stacking contest. We’re here to make something you can eat daily and feel good about.
Better Ingredients. Better Experience.
Here’s what makes Fit Butters deeper than macros:
- Premium dry roasted nuts (baked, never fried)
- Added protein to create a more complete protein source (and add flavor!)
- Healthy fats from coconut oil - not a vegetable or seed oil
- Real mix-ins in every jar
- Small-batch crafted flavor development
Regular peanut butter is basic fuel. This is performance fuel with personality.
The benefits aren’t just in the numbers — they’re in the ingredient quality, the digestibility, and the flavor experience.
Mission-Driven Flavor Lovers
✔ The lifter who still wants dessert
✔ The macro tracker who refuses to eat boring food
✔ The busy parent who wants a smarter sweet option
✔ The athlete who wants more than plain nut butter
This isn’t for someone looking for frosting in a jar. This is for someone building something — muscle, discipline, momentum.
TOPPED WITH REAL M&MS!
We don't go cheap with our inclusions. Every jar of Monster Cookie peanut butter is hand topped with authentic M&Ms and Ghirardelli dark chocolate chips.
Don't worry, if you don't see them as soon as you open the lid, know that they are in there and they probably sunk into the butter. A quick stir of a spoon and BOOM, you should see them!
We buy all of the peanuts we use directly from the farm and then dry-roast them, not fry them in oil. This makes for a higher quality protein peanut butter and better tasting too!